Here are our spare Butter Lids.
To see Photos click on HERE by the pattern name.
Some EAPG butter lids have a rim around their base that fits down into the butter base. 
We call that protruding rim a 'flange'.
The abbreviation "OD" means Outside Diameter and "ID" means Inside Diameter.
These prices do not include the cost of
shipping & insurance.
COLOR PATTERN ITEM Condition PRICE
Clear Acorn band- type 2 (variant) see HERE lid, butter 5 1/2" diam; edge ground; finial good; See McCain Pl. 198 $45.00
Clear Actress, OMN Opera see HERE lid, butter flange 5 5/8"; chip on finial tip $48.00
Vaseline Opalescent ALASKA; LION'S LEG see HERE butter lid & cracked base one tip on top of finial nicked; See Cov'd HERE; See base HERE $95.00
Clear ALBION- BRYCE see HERE lid, butter Fits over 4 1/2”; stippled pattern $45.00
Clear Almond thumbprint; pointed thumbprint; almond; finger print
see HERE
lid, butter or compote Flint. cable around outer edge; flint; flange fits inside 5 1/2” opening; see HERE $45.00
Clear APOLLO;SHIELD BAND; Canadian Horseshoe, Frosted Festal Ball, Thumbprint and Prisms see HERE lid, butter Domed; engraved; see HERE $44.00
Clear ARCH & FORGET-ME-NOT BANDS (PANELS) see HERE lid, butter Cross finial; 5 1/4" ID & 5 5/8" OD $35.00
Clear/ Ruby ART; JOB’S TEARS see HERE lid, butter Lid only; Base as is; badly damaged $65.00
Clear Atlanta; fostoria #500; clear lion heads, square lion heads, late lion see HERE lid, butter As Is; large chip on edge $35.00
Clear Atlanta; fostoria #500; clear lion heads, square lion heads, late lion see HERE lid, butter repaired ; chip ground from base. $45.00
Clear Atlanta; Fostoria #500; clear lion heads, square lion heads, late lion see HERE lid, butter 5 1/2” square; no harm flake on underside of edge. $75.00
Clear/Pink/
Yellow
Beaded Swirl & Disc in color! See HERE lid, butter Fits inside 5 1/2" $20.00
Clear Bellflower; Ribbed Bellflower see HERE lid, butter 5 3/4" OD; SV, FR see edge chip HERE & under edge flake HERE

$42.00

Clear Banded Raindrops; Cole; Candlewick
see HERE
lid, butter 5 1/2” OD; 5 1/8” inside diam $35.00
Clear Bleeding heart see HERE lid, butter 5 3/8" OD; 5” ID $65.00
Clear/ Ruby Blocked Thumbprint band; Duncan’s # 56 see HERE lid, butter
$45.00
Clear Broken Column; Rattan see HERE lid, butter 5 1/8” OD inside ribs $65.00
Clear CABLE;ATLANTIC CABLE see HERE lid, butter Flint; chips $48.00
vaseline CATHEDRAL; ORION see HERE lid, butter 4 5/8" Outside lip $43.00
Clear CLEAR FLOWER BAND see HERE lid, butter 6” x 4 3/4”; cross bar & circle finial; SEE LEE 1 pl 107 $35.00
Clear Crystal Wedding see HERE lid, butter 5” sq. ; lid is good; base has a few chips on edge $85.00
Clear CURTAIN TIE-BACK see HERE lid, Butter 4 5/8" ID; 5" OD; SL. RIM ROUGHNESS $34.00
Clear CUT LOG; ETHOL see HERE lid, butter or cheese Dome shaped; 5 7/8" od; rim small chip $65.00
Clear DAHLIA see HERE lid Butter? 5 3/8" OD 5" ID; slight outer edge mold roughness $32.00
Clear PEARL aka Daisy & Button w/ oval medallion; panelled daisy see HERE lid, butter 5 1/4” flange OD $25.00
VASELINE Daisy & Button W/ V ORNAMENT;
Vandyke see HERE
lid, butter 5 1/2” OD (no flange) $65.00
Clear Darling Grape; Late Panelled Grape; Indiana #154 see HERE lid, butter
$35.00
Clear Dart see HERE lid, butter 5 1/4" OD $38.00
Clear Deer & Pinetree; Deer & Doe see HERE lid, butter 5 1/4" x 3 3/4" flange flakelet on rim. $49.00
Clear

DIAGONAL BAND; DIAGONAL BLOCK & FAN see HERE

Lid, butter? 5 3/4" flange (fits inside 5 3/4") $35.00
Clear DOUBLE SPEAR; BRILLIANT see HERE lid, butter? 5 9/16" OD; a little usual inside edge mold roughness $35.00
Clear/ Amber Ellrose; Amberette; daisy & Button - Panelled - Single Scallop see HERE lid, butter 5 3/8” OD (no flange) $85.00
Clear Fan (s) w/ Diamond (s); shell; Mckee #3 see HERE lid, butter 5 5/8” OD; some minor roughness and one flat flake under edge of lid; not domed $35.00
Clear FEATHER; DORIC see HERE lid, butter 5 1/4" OD; inside rim roughness $32.00
Clear FESTOON see HERE lid, butter 4 1/2" ID X 4 3/4" OD;only very MINOR inside rim roughness $36.00
Clear FINE PRISM; PRISM see HERE Lid Butter? FLINT; 5 1/8"ID 5 1/2" OD $55.00
Clear Flower & Quill; Pretty Band see HERE lid, butter 5” O D square $30.00
Clear/ frosted Frosted Circle; Horn of Plenty
see HERE
lid, butter, jelly? 4 5/8” flange $34.00
Clear/ frosted

Frosted Eagle, Frosted Hawk; Old Abe
see HERE

lid; Butter Mint; flange fits inside 5 1/2" opening $95.00
Clear Grape W/ Scroll Medallion see HERE Lid Butter? 5 1/2" OD; See Welker 8-47 photo $25.00
Clear Heart w/ Thumbprint see HERE lid, butter
$125.00
Clear Heart w/ Thumbprint see HERE lid, butter
$125.00
Clear Hickman; Le Clede see HERE lid, butter? 4 3/4" flange $35.00
Clear HOME; Square In Diamond Bands
see HERE
Lid, Butter? 2 Flakes-top of edge $32.00
Clear/ engraved Jersey Lily ware; Lily Langtree; Lacy Valence; Center Medallion see HERE lid, butter engraved; 5 7/8" x 3 7/8" Outside; no flange $65.00
Clear Jersey Lily ware; Lily Langtree; Lacy Valence; Center Medallion see HERE lid, butter 3 7/8” x 5 7/8” outside dimensions; d/n fit our bases $65.00
Clear

JUMBO See HERE,  HERE &   HERE

lid, butter Fern/ flower engraved; fits inside 5 1/4"; 5 1/8" flange; chip on one side of tail; flake on tusks. $95.00
Clear Keystone, Mc Kee’s HERE & HERE lid, butter or compote rectangle; $35.00
Clear Lily of the Valley; May Flower
HERE
lid, butter or compote Fits over 5 5/8" $88.00
Clear LOOP WITH DEWDROPS see HERE lid, butter Fit in 4 3/4" base- 2 dings on points on outer lower edge $26.00
Clear LOOP WITH DEWDROPS see HERE lid, Butter Fit in 4 3/4" base- Butter? slight roughness on lower edge of top. $26.00
Clear LOOP WITH DEWDROPS see HERE lid, butter Fit in 4 3/4" base. $32.00
Clear Maine; stippled panelled flower; panelled flower; stippled primrose see HERE lid, butter 5” OD $75.00
Clear/ blush/ gold

Michigan; panelled jewel; loop & pillar; Desplaines see HERE & HERE

lid, butter domed; great blush & gold $88.00
Clear MORNING GLORY see HERE lid, butter fits over 5 9/16” base $275.00
Clear Nail; Recessed Pillar see HERE lid, butter engraved; Has base but is cracked & worthless
$55.00
Clear/ gold NEW JERSEY; LOOPS & DROPS see HERE lid, butter some gold; 5 1/8” OD; 4 3/4” ID $38.00
Clear Ohio see HERE lid, butter Fix; etched; 4 5/8” ID; small chip inside edge $38.00
Clear Panelled Thistle; delta see HERE lid, butter domed; glows yellow; 5 1/4" OD $55.00
Vaseline Petticoat; Riverside National see HERE lid, butter no gold; See HERE $95.00
Clear Pineapple, Higbee's see HERE & HERE lid, butter? 5 3/8" OD; 5" ID; Roughness on ledge under finial; Pineapple finial OK $45.00
Clear PLUME see HERE lid Butter? 5 1/4" Ins. diam; 5 5/8" OD $37.00
Clear Ranson; gold band see HERE lid, butter poor gold $55.00
Clear REVERSE TORPEDO ; Bullseye & Diamond Point; Dalzell #490D see HERE lid, butter 4 3/4 Outer dim; square; SOME ROUGH SPOTS $48.00
Clear RIBBED GRAPE; RAISIN see HERE lid, butter Flint; 5 9/16" OD; 1” very thin crack from edge $44.00
Clear ROCHELLE; PRINCESS FEATHER see HERE lid, butter? small rim chip; 4 15/16" OD $35.00
Clear ROPE BANDS; ARGENT; CLEAR PANELS W/ CORD BAND see HERE lid, butter Flange 5” $35.00
Clear SHELL & TASSEL; DUNCAN #155 see HERE lid, butter (251) square 5 1/2"; shell finial $75.00
Clear SHELL & TASSEL; DUNCAN #155
see HERE & HERE
lid, butter? (403) 5 1/4” square; flat chip and 2 flakes on rim edge $55.00
Clear Shuttle; hearts of loch laven; RIBBED ASTERISK & CONCAVE see HERE lid, butter 5 5/8" OD $75.00
Clear SUNFLOWER; LILY see HERE lid, butter? Fit inside 5 5/8" Circle Finial $45.00
Clear Tennessee; jewelled rosettes; jewel & crescent see HERE lid, butter 5 1/4" ID x 5 3/4" OD $45.00
Clear PLAIN; Unknown finial- hand holding ball or egg with dent in top see HERE & HERE & HERE Lid, butter? rim fits inside 5 1/4" $42.00
Clear VICTORIA- FOSTORIA'S see HERE lid, butter top of finial has been ground $85.00
Clear/ frosted Viking; centennial-hobbs; bearded head, bearded prophet, old man of the mountains see HERE & HERE lid, butter Fits inside 5 1/2"; Flea bite on tip of finial; Frosted finial $55.00
Clear WESTWARD HO; PIONEER
See HERE
lid, butter
old; 5 7/8” OD; 5 1/2” ID; have 6 photos; ask if interested in buying
apple green WILDFLOWER; ADAM’S #140
see HERE
lid, butter Chip on flange inside rim; flange fits inside 5 1/2” $66.00
Clear WOODEN PAIL; OAK BUCKET See HERE lid, butter? 5 1/2" flange; one small chip on inside flange $38.00
Clear WOODEN PAIL; OAK BUCKET see HERE lid. butter? 5 1/2” flange $45.00
Clear ZIG ZAG; Bryce Bros #126; Mitred Bars; Mitred Diamond Points; Mitred Diamond see HERE & HERE lid, butter 5 1/4" X 6 3/8" OD; SQUIRREL W/ NUT FINIAL $98.00